PARTIALLY INSTALL BATH DRAIN Install the drain on the bath according to the drain manufacturers instructions. Use a wrench/Channellock to disconnect the locknut holding the flange in place and remove it together with the washerClean the top of the sink as well as underneath the drain flange.Just like with the kitchen sink flange, apply a good size of plumbers putty or silicone caulk bead under the rim of the flange.More items The specialty finish on some drain assemblies can also be damaged from being in contact with plumbers putty. I read that plumber's putty can stain acrylic sinks, so I've seen silicone caulk recommended instead. The Loctite 1716864 Tube Plumber and Marine Adhesive is the second product on our list today and is another best plumber putty alternative. I also filled the remaining pocket holes in the legs with water putty. Apparently silicone expands and contracts with temperature changes, which makes it not seal well. Granted, it took 8 years for it to start leaking, but when I replaced the drain this time I used plumbers putty. Put on plenty so it oozes out all around the flange. It worked beautifully. 5 Ways of Sealing Bathtub Drain. Knead the putty and roll into a rope about thick. Fit the drain or fixture into place, and this will ensure a watertight fit and limit the chances of having a leak They'll likely need a second application. Can't say the same about plumbers putty. This item: 9 oz. Silicone; Silicone caulk is less durable as it loses flexibility once dry and can be worn down by heavy water exposure. In most of the cases, it takes several hours to dry completely. If you apply it at the base of a faucet to stop the leakage of water, you have to wait for several hours before it dries out quickly. You will have to know about the plumbers putty dry time. After some intervals, keep checking it is has dried up or not. Channellock Pliers. 09-30-2007, 02:47 PM. I think you guys are talking about two different methods. Its flexible and made to seal plumbing gaps whenever necessary, enabling you to achieve a 100% water-proof seal with just a dab and smudge! Tighten the locking nuts snugly (do not over-tighten drain connections). However, a plumber I spoke to said that the silicone will lose its seal and stiffen up within a few years, causing water to leak from the drain. Why Use Plumber's Putty . I purchased a Kohler K-1123-LA-0 tub with the K-7272 drain kit to replace an older tub. Be careful not to scratch the surface of the product. $3.30. What should I use, silicone caulk? Due to too much moisture, the caulk around the bathtub gets damaged. Q Can Stain-Free plumber's putty be used when installing the drain on an Acrylic tub and / or shower unit? Apply 100% neutral cure silicone sealant or plumbers putty to the underside of the drain flange and slide down through the tub drain opening and connect to the drain line assembly, tail piece and P trap. 7. Mount the vertical rod or the= ball on vertical support and the horizontal rod or the flat on the arm, NOT= the other way around! Follow these basic steps to apply plumbers putty:Scoop out a ball of putty from the tub with your fingers.Roll the putty back and forth between open palms to create a continuous rope (much like making a snake out of Play-Doh). Lay the putty rope into place on the part you want to seal, starting at any point and working in a continuous loop, running around the part and meeting back Gently press the rope into place without deforming it. This is just to keep it from coming to lose when you turn the part right side up. Install the part as required. When you tighten down the part, putty will likely squeeze out from the edges; this is desirable, as it means you used plenty of putty. So I'm looking for siliconized acrylic tub sealer latex but I can't find it anywhere. Color Code Description S Polished Stainless BS Brushed Stainless BL Matte Black 1-800-4KOHLER (1-800-456-4537) Push the flange inside the drain opening. BoJangles | Apr 15, 2007 03:00am | #3. Hunker may earn compensation through affiliate links in this story. Sort by move or install cast iron tubs. Both plumbers putty and silicone are sealing compounds designed to provide a water tight fit for pop up drains, sink strainers, undersides of fittings, showers and drains. Items needed to remove and replace a modern screw in bath tub drain (not all drains are like this). How To Seal A Sink Drain Plumber S Putty Vs Silicone Caulk Plumbing Sniper. Tub Drain Removal Tool. Tub instructions say to follow the drain instructions. 4. 10-15-2007, 01:07 PM. Tub Drain Extractor Tool for 1.5 Drains or. Both plumbers putty and silicone caulk can be used to seal a sink drain. Apr 11, 2012. I've also heard of using stainless plumber's putty. The main purpose of this product is to create a seal between a tap and the kitchen worktop. Harvey Siliconized Acrylic Caulk is a water-based acrylic caulk with silicone for added adhesion and low temperature flexibility. I was looking up instructions for my new-ish tub and was very surprised to find that silicone caulking was the recommended material for my tub - apparently plumber's putty does not get along with acrylic tubs? Once you put pressure on the joint, old plumber's putty usually breaks apart readily, and you should be able to remove the bulk of it with your fingers. 13 Plumbing Tricks Of The Trade For Weekend Plumbers. Apparently silicone expands and contracts with temperature changes, which makes it not seal well. con: staining, may or may not eat tub/fittings. But make sure youre using 100% silicone without any mixture of acrylic latex. Silicone is a 100% waterproof sealant that doesnt turn pale over time. All we use it plumbers putty for attaching pieces to fixtures. Its flexible and made to seal plumbing gaps whenever necessary, enabling you to achieve a 100% water-proof seal with just a dab and smudge! When only a silicone or latex sealer is called for, it should be used. To take it off, use a utility knife. First, lets break down the ingredients and It will not harden, shrink, crack or crumble. The last time the repair was relatively simple since there is an access panel that allowed the drain basket to be easily removed and reinstalled with fresh plumbers putty. I always use 100% silicone. Cut off the excess putty. then a non silicone caulk. Glacier Bay Fixed Post Kitchen Sink Strainer - Stainless steel with polished finish. Now we have to start a new tally. Both plumber's putty and silicone caulk provide a watertight seal for a sink drain. Petroleum based sealers, like plumbers putty, react with the plastics, and will at best discolor the drain or fixture and at worst cause the drain to break or distort. The material makes waterproof seals with wet surfaces. K-23726 Drain treatment K-23723 Faucet cleaner Codes/Standards ASME A112.18.2/CSA B125.2 KOHLER One-Year Limited Warranty See website for detailed warranty information. the same effect on ABS (Acrylonitrile Butadiene Styrene) materials. Yes, Silicone can be used as an alternative to plumbers putty. Plumbers use it because it remains soft for a long time and maintains a watertight seal, but unlike silicone and other types of caulk, plumber's putty is not an adhesive, so a fixture or drain part sealed with putty remains easy to remove if you ever need to replace it. Both plumbers putty and silicone are sealing compounds designed to provide a water tight fit for pop up drains, sink strainers, undersides of fittings, showers and drains. Oatey, Hercules and Harvey Plumbers Putty helps provide a waterproof seal between two rigid surfaces. Plumbers putty formula will not crack or shrink. C. PROTECT BATH UNIT Position a drop cloth or similar material in the bottom of the unit. 100% is too tuff to work with and it smells. There is, however, another leak around the shower doors. Is there another make of stainless putty that is ok to use on acrylic tub drains? Thread Sealing PTFE Plumber's Tape. We have decided to use the easy tactic and use silicone caulk. You just introduced a new factor. Loctite is another manufacturer that we trust, especially because of the attention to detail within their products. To get the rest off, a little light scraping with a putty knife is all it usually takes, but there may be a thin film of dried linseed oil left over. Add 100% silicone Caulk under in between the chrome and the white upper portion of the tub. 100% is too tuff to work with and it smells. Put the item in place and apply pressure so that excess putty oozes out from under items flange. If you are unable to access the underside of the drainage pipe below the tub, you can use silicone caulk on the exposed area of the drain to help create a watertight seal. Plumbers putty is a long-lasting, easy to use fixture setting compound for setting frames, faucets, bath wastes and basket strainers. Plumbers putty is more traditional while silicone caulking is a more modern product, but either one (in most cases) can get the job done. Apply plumbers putty to the washer and slide it over the bottom of the drain body. Can I use plumbers putty instead of Silicone? When only a silicone or latex sealer is called for, it should be used. i hope you don't caulk toilets with silicone. Plumbers Putty vs Silicone: Their Ingredients. Step 3: Clean the Seating Area and Apply Fresh Plumbers Putty. Plumbers putty is a pliable clay-like substance and the uses are to create seals around faucets and drains. print Print. The raw Silicone would be waterproof and seal better, as well as the plumbers putty. Screwdriver. Do you need plumbers putty on a tub drain? Permanently reinstall the drain assembly. x 260 in. ABF Installation with access under the floor (continued) Install Drain Hardware Apply a bead of clear silicone or plumbers putty around the drain body and pass it through the drain hole. rick. For more than 75 years, Harvey has offered a wide variety of plumbing supplies for residential and commercial applications. Put some meat on it and tighten the miss up then clean the clear silicone caulk off the top. Jun 10, 2008 I just heard this you shouldn't use plumber's putty on acrylic tubs or sink drains because it weakens the plastic and it will eventually cause cracks. #2. Plumbers putty can be easily moved by hand whereas you will need tools and patience to remove silicon caulk. Applying Plumbers Putty on the Sink Drain Flange Scoop a generous amount of plumbers putty and roll it between the palm of your hands into a long-pencil sized bead. 169 Plumbers putty is one of the basics tools in a plumber's tool bag. But I thought the seal would have lasted longer than 3 years. The mating surfaces of these parts are typically metallic and ceramic, but if they were made of PVC and the installation requires the use of plumbers putty there would be no problem using putty. PVC doesn't react with linseed oil (which along with clay) is a component of plumbers putty. It is tack free in 30 minutes, and paintable in two hours with latex or oil-based paints. Or is standard plumber's putty fine for Acrylic? View More Details. there is an acrylic caulk with silicone that's a water base and it's fine. Some require silicone because it doesn't stain. South Loop Store. if you replace. There is no issue using plumber's putty and ABS piping materials. Compound designed for stainless-steel sealing applications. Putty on the tub, silicone on the shower. $ 1 57. Plumbers putty is a leak waiting to happen. Silicone - pro: no staining. 09-30-2007, 02:47 PM. Drain Key for Unlocking or Installing Drains. Do I Need Plumber S Putty For A Sink Drain Apartminty. Plumber's putty forms a tight, waterproof seal in wet areas. 6. Pipe dope the threads on the chrome and never hurts to pipe dope that black rubber. Follow. $9.98. Once the caulk dries, it forms a firm seal that won't wash away. Plumbers putty is probably the product youre searching for. Plumber?s Putties could have an adverse effect on the Acrylic finish similar to the same effect on ABS (Acrylonitrile Butadiene Styrene) materials. #2. Ease the putty into a ring that matches the circumference of the drain or bottom of the faucet fixture. If you are unable to access the underside of the drainage pipe below the tub, you can use silicone caulking on the exposed area of the drain to help create a watertight seal. Only show this user. If it still leaks your tub is defective. 100% Silicone Caulk. I used silicone on an acrylic shower drain 8 years ago because that's what the instructions said and had major leak because it didn't last. INSTALL THE BATH A. BATH SET-IN Choose the installation option (Step 1., 2., or 3. below) Mark. Oatey Fastape 1/2 in. Both plumber's putty and silicone caulk provide a watertight seal for a sink drain. putty on 95% of everything except natural stone/ marble. Plumbers putty is extremely durable as the putty remains in a malleable form. Furthermore, it doesnt turn yellow, shrink, or crack in any type of condition. This time when I removed the drain basket again the plumbers putty was dry and crumbling. Plumbers Putty Or Silicone To Seal Bathtub Drain Sink Bath Usually. Step 2: Remove the Old Drain. Schedule 40 PVC, The Superior White Pipe. Universal Kit: The Lift and Turn bathtub drain stopper fits 1-3/8 inch (1-5/8" actual O.D.) there is an acrylic caulk with silicone that's a water base and it's fine. The answer with this one will differ between plumbers, but the fact is that either plumber's putty or silicone can be used in this case. $3.95. Re: Bathtub Drain Advice. putty on 95% of everything except natural stone/ marble. Available Colors/Finishes Color tiles intended for reference only. They both require little preparation, are generally very safe to use, and are must-have tools in most plumbers toolboxes. 3. Start by slowly scratching the damaged caulk. There may be other times that tape or caulk are better options. In the last week I've had both a sink drain rubber washer and a tub drain rubber washer leak o n me. Of course, I did use plumber's putty in the usual place, beneath the drain flange. However, they are made from very different ingredients which affect the diversity of their use. con: have to wait before testng, harder to remove. Y. The same applies to piping; don't use regular (petro based) pipe thread compound on PVC pipe. The gasket on the bottom seals the water inside the drain system. A bathtub drain seal is essential, but the tub drain silicone or plumber's putty takes quite a beating. Tweet. USAnigel | Apr 15, 2007 02:54am | #2. First find out if plumbers putty if ok to use on your acrylic tub[probably not]. No. Glue one to the head of an SS bolt and the other to=20= the end of the arm with two part modified acrylic glue. Insert the Drain Key into the drain. Here are the supplies you need. Looking to create a water-tight seal around the sinks, drains, and faucets in your home? then a non silicone caulk. Plumbers putty is probably the product youre searching for. rick. Putty - pro: can test connection immidately, can be removed easily. Once the tub is set over the W&O you install the drain flange and overflow plate onto the W&O. Q Can Stain-Free plumber's putty be used when installing the drain on an Acrylic tub and / or shower unit? Thread the locking nut provided onto the bottom of the basket and turn it clockwise to tighten. So I used a substance I have used successfully before, a substance that looks like it's silicone but lacks that acetic acid smell and is both harder and tougher than the usual stuff that comes out of the tube: Shoe Goo. Tweet. For the drain itself, plumbers putty is the best solution. Apply Plumbers Putty The putty will help the upper part of the drain assembly seal against the sink drain opening. The silicone or putty goes on the underside of the thing you screw on. . Just use some thread sealer paste. and 1-1/2 inch (1-7/8" actual O.D.) He replaced the silicone around the drain with plumber's putty and the leak stopped. That would mean no regular putty. As for putty, that apparently depends on the tub material. Acrylic-latex caulks can take up to 72 hours to reach full cure. Plumbers putty That is unless plumbers putty will cause damage to their unit, then you will see a warning notice with the tub documentation not to use plumbers putty. the same effect on ABS (Acrylonitrile Butadiene Styrene) materials. Bathtub drain could be sealed in various ways. It seems like they're just so prone to going off center and then compromising the water proof conne read more. Plumbers putty is more traditional while silicone caulking is a more modern product, but either one (in most cases) can get the job done. Can Stain-Free plumber?s putty be used when installing the drain on an Acrylic tub and / or shower unit? These Amazon links help support Home Repair Tutor, many thanks for using them. Tub-N-Tile caulk, a specialty acrylic-latex caulk, also includes an advanced mildewcide, defending against mildew growth in damp areas. Re: Silicone or plumber's putty? Do not over-tighten. This is often where the water sneaks through! Oatey and Hercules offer a stain-free plumbers putty for Part of your job as a professional is knowing when to use witch product in which situation. Add to cart. He replaced the silicone around the drain with plumber's putty and the leak stopped. 5. In fact, Oatey's putty says DO NOT USE ON PLASTIC on the warning label. Many people agree that plumber putty is usually used for the details, and silicon caulking is used for bigger jobs. Silicone is to be used as caulking to seal edges like the skirt of a toilet or the edge of a drop in stainless sink. Its easy to apply on windows, kitchen, bath, gutters, and automobiles, but mostly used in plumbing maintenance. Maintenance. Apply Teflon tape to the threaded portion of the drain body. Share Save Comment 4. B. Otherwise water will leak out between the two and begin dripping under the sink. The shower does not have that secondary seal. I'll be interested to see other responses. Plumber's putty forms a tight, waterproof seal in wet areas around bathtub plumbing. Check the threads where the rubber "washer" sits. Form a complete circle with the putty around the underside of the flange of the item you are installing. I usually file a sha= llow V first to locate the shank mechanically. Plumbers putty may sometimes be used to stop a leak but it isnt always the best solution. Apply the bead of plumbers putty under the rip of the sink flange to form a perfect circle underneath it. The reason being that the putty in the tub just prevents the water from leaking around the threads and into the drain. In this discussion, Shader states: "The acrylics used in todays plumbing fixtures are a whole new ball game. I ordered some more silicone-cushioned pipe clamps from McMaster-Carr. Both plumber's putty and silicone caulk provide a watertight seal for a sink drain. Durable Material: The bath tub drain kit is made of high-purity brass, with matte black finished, matches with other brands matte black bathroom fixtures. Silicone if a one time install shower pan on slab on grade ect ect . Advertisement. P/N 3225T67 are for the 3/4" pipe, P/N 3225T65 are for the 1/2" pipe. Looking to create a water-tight seal around the sinks, drains, and faucets in your home? Is it better to use plumbers putty or silicone? CJT, Adam is telling you to set the W&O up on the drain first then set the tub over the made up assembly. Drain instruction says to use "non oil based caulking compound". Petroleum based sealers, like plumbers putty, react with the plastics, and will at best discolor the drain or fixture and at worst cause the drain to break or distort. Re: Silicone or plumber's putty? I personally use 100% silicone on all my tub/shower drain assemblies, pop-ups, basket strainers, unless instructions I've never had a leak yet. Plumbers Putty Vs Silicone Caulk Head To Comparison. Its one of the alternatives to plumbers putty. Here is the detailed process: Step 1: Scrape the Caulk. Product remains flexible and resilient. 5. There is, however, another leak around the shower doors. This secures the basket in place. seanny deep said: Putty if you can access it to replace ex vanity,kitchen sink , bathtub with unfinished basement. Plumbers Putty or. i hope you don't caulk toilets with silicone. Plumber putty is easy to apply and works especially well in smaller spaces, while silicon caulking is better for a larger job that is easier to maintain. Stain-Free Plumber's Putty. Once the caulking dries, it forms a firm seal that won't wash away. Not for use on plastic, marble, granite or dimensional stones. If you do not have plumbers putty or cannot use it on your type of sink, then you can use silicone or even the foam or rubber gasket that comes with some pop-up assemblies. bathtub waste elbows, meets the most exiting bathroom bathtubs. You must seal the area between a sink's drain body and the actual sink surface. Yes, you can use plumbers putty as the alternative to Silicone. That goes for pop-ups, strainer baskets, shower drains depending on the style.